Skip to content

Chapter 7: Locating Features

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Measurement Systems
  3. Establishing Origins and Datums
  4. Surface Detection Methods
  5. Edge Finding Techniques
  6. Coordinate System Management
  7. Calculating Tool Offsets
  8. Error Management Strategies
  9. Milling Strategies
  10. Practical Applications
  11. Quality Considerations
  12. Summary

Introduction

Precise feature location is fundamental to successful machining operations. While layout and manual positioning methods can achieve accuracy within approximately 0.005 inches, machine-based positioning methods utilize the mill's inherent precision to locate features with significantly higher accuracy. This chapter covers the essential techniques for establishing reference points, measuring distances, and positioning features on workpieces.

The foundation of accurate feature location lies in establishing a consistent coordinate system. All dimensions should be measured from a single reference corner in three-dimensional space, creating what machinists call an "origin" or "datum." This approach ensures that any dimensional errors in the stock material are pushed to a single location rather than being distributed throughout the part.

Measurement Systems

Digital Readouts vs Hand Wheels

Modern mills employ two primary measurement systems for positioning work:

Hand Wheels: Traditional graduated wheels that indicate table travel through lead screw rotation. These systems require careful backlash management and provide resolution typically limited to 0.001 inches.

Digital Readouts (DROs): Electronic systems using optical scales to measure table travel directly. DROs eliminate backlash concerns and provide resolution to 0.0001 inches or better.

Backlash Management

When using hand wheel systems, backlash control is critical for accurate positioning. Backlash occurs due to clearances in the lead screw mechanism and manifests as lost motion when changing direction.

Best Practices for Backlash Control:

  • Establish your approach direction before beginning measurements
  • Never change direction once zero is established
  • If direction change is necessary, move beyond the target, then approach from the original direction
  • Maintain consistent approach direction for all related measurements

Establishing Origins and Datums

Origin Selection

Select one corner of the workpiece as the origin point, typically the corner that provides the most logical reference for all features. All subsequent measurements should reference this single point to maintain dimensional relationships regardless of stock material variations.

Three-Dimensional Referencing

A complete origin requires establishment of three reference points:

  1. X-axis reference: One vertical edge of the workpiece
  2. Y-axis reference: One horizontal edge of the workpiece
  3. Z-axis reference: The top surface of the workpiece

Surface Detection Methods

Touching Off Method

The simplest method for establishing a Z-axis reference involves bringing a rotating cutter into light contact with the workpiece surface.

Procedure:

  1. Install appropriate cutter and start spindle at low speed
  2. Position cutter above workpiece surface
  3. Use fine feed controls to lower cutter slowly
  4. Watch for initial chip formation indicating surface contact
  5. Zero the vertical measurement system at this point

Accuracy: Approximately 0.001-0.002 inches, with the cutter ending slightly below the true surface.

Shim Stock Method

This method uses precision thickness gauges to establish more accurate surface reference.

Procedure:

  1. Position rotating cutter slightly above workpiece
  2. Insert known thickness shim stock between cutter and surface
  3. Lower cutter until light drag is felt on the shim
  4. Remove shim and adjust measurement system by shim thickness
  5. Zero the measurement system

Accuracy: Within 0.0005 inches, depending on shim precision.

Paper Method

Uses standard copy paper (approximately 0.004 inches thick) as a thickness gauge.

Procedure:

  1. Insert paper between rotating cutter and workpiece
  2. Lower cutter until it grasps and pulls the paper
  3. Account for paper thickness in measurement system
  4. Zero after compensating for paper thickness

Accuracy: Within 0.0005 inches, though requires hand placement near rotating cutter.

Edge Finding Techniques

Edge Finder Operation

Edge finders provide the most precise method for locating workpiece edges. These tools consist of a precision ground arbor with a spring-loaded, moveable shaft that "kicks over" when contacting a machined surface.

Components:

  • Precision ground arbor for chuck mounting
  • Spring-loaded shaft of known diameter
  • Typically 0.200 inches diameter for common edge finders

Operating Procedure:

  1. Mount edge finder in spindle
  2. Start spindle at approximately 1000 RPM
  3. Position edge finder near workpiece edge
  4. Slowly advance until shaft centers itself against workpiece
  5. Continue advancing until shaft kicks to one side
  6. Note position when kickover occurs
  7. Zero measurement system, then offset by edge finder radius

Edge Finder Limitations

Edge finders work effectively only on:

  • Machined surfaces perpendicular to the spindle axis
  • Surfaces with adequate hardness for the kickover mechanism
  • Clean surfaces free of burrs or irregular features

They cannot reliably locate:

  • Rough or soft surfaces
  • Angled surfaces
  • Irregular profiles

Coordinate System Management

Absolute Positioning Mode

In absolute mode, all measurements reference the established origin point. This mode maintains the primary coordinate system throughout the machining operation.

Incremental Positioning Mode

Incremental mode creates a temporary coordinate system that can be zeroed independently of the absolute origin. This mode proves valuable for:

  • Temporary measurements without losing the primary origin
  • Calculating intermediate positions
  • Setting up secondary reference points

Datum Point Systems

Advanced DRO systems allow storage of multiple reference points, enabling:

  • Quick return to established positions
  • Management of multiple coordinate systems on complex parts
  • Efficient setup for families of similar parts

Calculating Tool Offsets

Cutter Radius Compensation

When positioning cutters for feature creation, the relationship between spindle centerline and cutting edge must be considered.

For External Features (shelves, steps): Position = Feature dimension - Cutter radius

For Internal Features (slots, pockets): Position = Feature dimension + Cutter radius

Example Calculation: To create a 0.250-inch wide shelf using a 0.500-inch diameter cutter:

  • Cutter radius = 0.250 inches
  • Required position = 0.250 - 0.250 = 0.000 inches from origin
  • Spindle centerline positioned at origin will place cutting edge at desired feature location

Error Management Strategies

Error Distribution Philosophy

Manufacturing errors cannot be eliminated entirely but can be strategically directed to minimize their impact on part function.

Primary Principle: Push all dimensional errors to a single, non-critical area of the part rather than distributing them throughout multiple features.

Centerline vs. Edge Referencing

For features specified as centered on the workpiece, two approaches exist:

Edge Reference Method:

  • Measure from established origin to feature location
  • Maintains precise relationship to reference edges
  • Accumulates stock dimension errors in feature centering

Centerline Method:

  • Locate both edges and calculate true center
  • Ensures feature is precisely centered regardless of stock variations
  • May introduce small errors in edge relationships

Selection Criteria

Choose the appropriate method based on:

  • Critical dimensions specified on drawings
  • Part function requirements
  • Tolerance relationships between features

Milling Strategies

Depth of Cut Planning

Feature creation typically requires multiple passes, particularly on smaller machines or when machining harder materials.

Factors Affecting Depth of Cut:

  • Machine rigidity and power
  • Workpiece material properties
  • Cutter size and geometry
  • Surface finish requirements

Conventional vs. Climb Milling

Conventional Milling: Cutter rotation opposes feed direction, providing better control on machines with backlash.

Climb Milling: Cutter rotation matches feed direction, producing superior surface finish but requiring rigid, backlash-free systems.

Multi-Pass Strategies

Sequential Depth Method:

  • Rough to depth at reduced width
  • Machine full width at final depth
  • Provides good dimensional control

Sequential Width Method:

  • Machine full depth at reduced width
  • Expand to full width with finishing passes
  • Optimizes surface finish

Practical Applications

Step Feature Creation

Process Overview:

  1. Establish workpiece origin using edge finding
  2. Calculate cutter offset for feature position
  3. Plan depth of cut strategy
  4. Execute roughing passes
  5. Measure and adjust for finishing pass
  6. Deburr and verify dimensions

Hole Positioning

Setup Considerations:

  • Center drill, drill, and ream operations require tool changes
  • Tool length variations necessitate Z-axis adjustment
  • Balance between setup time and positioning accuracy

Positioning Strategies:

  1. Individual Hole Method: Complete all operations on one hole before moving to the next
  2. Operation Grouping Method: Perform same operation on all holes before changing tools

Multiple Hole Accuracy

When positioning multiple holes, measurement method affects relative accuracy:

Hand Wheel Method: Requires careful backlash management between positions

DRO Method: Enables rapid, accurate return to established positions

Indicator Method: Provides verification of table travel for critical dimensions

Quality Considerations

Measurement and Verification

  • Remove burrs before measuring finished features
  • Use appropriate measuring tools for required accuracy
  • Verify critical dimensions during machining process

Surface Finish Optimization

  • Plan finishing passes at final dimensions
  • Consider cutter load and engagement for best surface quality
  • Balance cycle time against finish requirements

Tolerance Management

Match positioning method precision to drawing requirements:

  • Touch-off methods: ±0.002 inches typical
  • Edge finder methods: ±0.0005 inches typical
  • Electronic surface detection: ±0.0001 inches typical

Summary

Successful feature location combines proper setup procedures with appropriate measurement techniques. Understanding the capabilities and limitations of each method enables selection of the most efficient approach for specific applications. Whether using traditional hand wheel systems or modern DRO equipment, consistent application of these principles ensures accurate, repeatable results in machining operations.